Top 6 Super Bowl Exotic Bets on BettorEdge
- Greg Kajewski
- 18 hours ago
- 11 min read
BettorEdge offers a unique way to bet on Super Bowl LIX, scheduled for February 9, 2026, with its peer-to-peer platform that eliminates hidden fees and allows users to set custom odds. Here are six exotic bets that can add more fun to your game day:
First Halftime Song: Bet on which song Bad Bunny will perform first. Current favorite: "Titi Me Pregunto" (+125).
Time of Initial Kickoff: Wager on whether the kickoff will occur before or after 6:40 PM ET, factoring in typical pre-game delays.
Coin Flip Result: A classic 50/50 bet - heads or tails - with true odds and no bookmaker margin.
National Anthem Length: Predict whether Charlie Puth’s performance will go over or under 120 seconds.
Gatorade Color: Guess the color of the Gatorade poured on the winning coach. Blue and Orange are leading options.
Non-QB Touchdown Pass: Bet on whether a non-quarterback will throw a touchdown - rare but thrilling when it happens.
BettorEdge stands out with its community-driven features like group chats, leaderboards, and real-time odds, making these quirky bets more interactive. With no sportsbook cut, bettors can enjoy better pricing and higher potential returns. Whether you're a casual viewer or a seasoned bettor, these props bring an extra layer of fun to the big game.
1. First Halftime Song
Entertainment Value
Bad Bunny is set to headline the Super Bowl LX halftime show, and betting on his opening song adds an extra layer of fun for fans, especially those tuning in just for the halftime spectacle.
The current favorite for the opening song is "Titi Me Pregunto", priced at +125 (62¢). Other contenders include "BAILE INoLVIDABLE" at +240 (13¢), "MONACO" at +300, and "LA MuDANZA" at +430. Keep in mind, the market for this type of bet is highly speculative - any rumors about rehearsal setlists can cause significant shifts in odds as the game day approaches.
Historical Trends or Data
Looking at past Super Bowl halftime shows, performers tend to start with well-known hits. In fact, only 4 of the last 13 openers were songs less than three years old at the time of performance. Meanwhile, 7 of the last 13 opening songs were less than seven years old. This trend suggests that while newer tracks occasionally make the cut, established hits are more likely to set the tone for the show. Bettors can use this pattern to narrow down their choices.
Community Insights on BettorEdge
BettorEdge's active social features bring fans together to speculate and strategize around halftime show bets. The platform's social feed and group chats are buzzing with predictions, leaked rehearsal rumors, and debates over song choices. Users also monitor leaderboard activity to spot sharp betting trends. This lively interaction often creates short-term pricing inefficiencies, giving sharp bettors opportunities to gain an edge.
Custom Odds and Peer-to-Peer Features
BettorEdge’s peer-to-peer system offers a unique way to bet on props like the first halftime song. You can set your own odds or challenge friends directly, all without hidden fees. Whether you’re creating custom challenges or searching the marketplace for the best lines, BettorEdge makes betting on exotic props transparent and engaging. This flexibility adds another layer of excitement to the halftime show experience.
2. Time of Initial Kickoff
Entertainment Value
Betting on the kickoff time is a quick and exciting way to get in on the action. On BettorEdge, the over/under line is set at 6:40 PM ET, even though the game is officially scheduled for 6:30 PM ET. The reason? Pre-game ceremonies like the National Anthem and the coin toss often push the actual kickoff time back.
"Kickoff... is set for 6:30 p.m. ET, but often with sporting events there are delays as pre-game ceremonies run long." – Andrew Reid, Publishing Editor, Sportsbook Review
This makes it a fun wager: Will the NFL stick to its schedule, or will the ceremonies run long enough to push the kickoff past 6:40 PM ET?
Historical Trends or Data
Looking back, it's clear that scheduled 6:30 PM ET kickoffs rarely happen on time. Ceremony delays are so common that the 6:40 PM ET over/under line reflects this trend. This history adds an intriguing layer to the bet, sparking debates about whether this year will follow the same pattern.
Community Insights on BettorEdge
BettorEdge’s social features make even a bet on kickoff timing a lively experience. Group chats and leaderboards light up with chatter about pre-game ceremony lengths, and savvy bettors analyze past trends to predict whether the over or under will hit. This real-time interaction turns a simple timing prop into a dynamic and engaging event.
3. Coin Flip Result
Entertainment Value
The coin toss bet on BettorEdge is a perfect example of the simple thrills that make Super Bowl betting so engaging. It's a straightforward 50/50 proposition that kicks off the excitement before the game even begins. Over 59 Super Bowls, tails has come up 31 times, while heads has landed 28 times - a difference that's statistically negligible. Still, the saying "tails never fails" remains popular, even though 54% of tickets and 52% of the betting handle leaned toward heads for Super Bowl 60. This mix of superstition and chance keeps bettors coming back year after year.
Historical Trends or Data
The coin toss has an interesting track record. In the last 11 Super Bowls, tails has come up seven times. But here's the kicker: winning the coin toss doesn’t necessarily lead to winning the game. Out of the 59 Super Bowls, only 27 teams (45.7%) that won the toss actually went on to win the championship. As Nick Holz from Odds Shark points out:
"The coin toss winner has only gone on to win the Super Bowl twice in the last 10 contests".
The Kansas City Chiefs have been especially lucky, winning the coin toss in four of the last five Super Bowls. On the flip side, the longest streak for heads is five years, while tails has had four-year streaks on three separate occasions. These stats, combined with a bit of folklore, make the coin toss a hot topic for debate.
Community Insights on BettorEdge
BettorEdge's social feed buzzes with bets about the coin toss. Users dive into historical data, analyze recent outcomes, and speculate on whether this year will break any streaks. Thanks to BettorEdge's social betting model, both heads and tails are offered at true odds, with no house advantage. This makes the coin toss a pure 50/50 bet - exactly as it should be.
4. National Anthem Length
Entertainment Value
One of the quirkiest yet most popular Super Bowl bets revolves around the length of the national anthem. For Super Bowl LX, Charlie Puth's performance has an Over/Under line set at 120 seconds. This bet transforms the anthem from a ceremonial moment into a thrilling wager, keeping fans on edge from the very first note. Historically, the average duration of the anthem across 35 recorded Super Bowl performances is 114.8 seconds (or 1:54). However, styles range widely, from straightforward renditions to more theatrical interpretations, adding an extra layer of unpredictability.
Historical Trends and Data
Over the years, anthem performances have trended longer. In the 1990s, only two performances surpassed the two-minute mark. That number rose to four in the 2000s and five in the 2010s. Alicia Keys holds the record for the longest anthem at Super Bowl 47, clocking in at 2:36. More recent examples include Chris Stapleton's 2:01 in 2023, Jazmine Sullivan & Eric Church's 2:16 in 2021, Reba McEntire's quick 1:35 in 2024, and Jon Batiste's 1:59 in 2025. These variations make predicting the length an exciting challenge for bettors.
Community Insights on BettorEdge
On platforms like BettorEdge, anthem length predictions tap into the collective knowledge of the betting community. Users dive into performer histories and vocal styles to make educated guesses. The social feed buzzes with debates about whether the artist will stick to a traditional rendition or add their own flair. For the 2026 performance, the "Over" is priced at -125, while the "Under" sits at -105, hinting at a slight market lean toward a longer rendition. BettorEdge’s odds reflect community sentiment, helping bettors feel more confident and connected when placing their wagers.
5. Gatorade Color
Entertainment Value
Betting on the Gatorade color brings a playful twist to Super Bowl celebrations. For a full dive-in, check out our full analysis on Gatorade color. This prop bet turns the iconic post-game Gatorade shower into a guessing game, sparking curiosity and excitement. Fans dive into every detail, from practice footage to sideline snapshots and even social media posts, to make their predictions. It's no surprise this quirky wager has grown into a $100-million industry on its own, showing just how much people enjoy turning every moment into a betting opportunity.
Historical Trends and Data
When it comes to trends, Clear/Water leads the pack with 8 appearances, while Orange follows with 6. In recent years, Blue has become a favorite, showing up in 3 of the last 7 Super Bowls. Purple made waves by being the pick for back-to-back events in 2023 and 2024, with Yellow/Green making its mark in 2025. Interestingly, Red has yet to make an appearance in the 21st century, and Clear/Water has been missing since Super Bowl 42.
Team colors, surprisingly, don’t seem to influence the Gatorade choice much. Since 2001, the winning team’s jersey color has only matched the Gatorade color three times. For Super Bowl 60, the odds are shaping up like this: Orange at +250, Blue between +200 and +260, Yellow/Green at +260, and Purple sitting at +700 to +800. These numbers highlight how BettorEdge transforms small game-day details into engaging betting markets.
Community Insights on BettorEdge
The Gatorade color market thrives on last-minute tips and collaborative insights. BettorEdge’s social feed becomes a buzzing hub during the Super Bowl, filled with users exchanging observations, theories, and even hints from championship celebrations. Sharp bettors often analyze the colors used during the AFC and NFC Championship games, as teams sometimes stick with what worked before.
What sets BettorEdge apart is the way it fosters shared analysis. Rapid updates, group chats, and community speculation create an environment where bettors can pool their knowledge. This collective effort often uncovers value before traditional sportsbooks have time to adjust their odds, making the experience both interactive and rewarding.
6. Will a Non-QB Throw a Touchdown
Entertainment Value
Betting on a non-quarterback throwing a touchdown pass can add an exciting twist to your Super Bowl experience. These bets focus on trick plays - like when a running back or wide receiver takes on the role of the passer - catching both defenses and fans off guard. The thrill comes from the unpredictability, where every unusual formation or motion on the field could signal a game-changing moment.
"Sports betting sites love to get creative with their Super Bowl prop bets, and these are ideal markets for bettors who want a little variety on their wagering card." – Sportsbook Review
This type of bet rewards those who study coaching styles and play-calling creativity. Teams known for gadget plays or reverses are more likely to attempt these rare moves, giving observant bettors an advantage. Understanding the history of these plays can also help you make more informed wagers.
Historical Trends and Data
Only six non-quarterbacks have ever thrown a touchdown pass in Super Bowl history, which makes these plays both rare and highly unpredictable. The first instance occurred in 1978 during Super Bowl XII, with the most recent happening in 2024 at Super Bowl 58. Trick plays like the famous "Philly Special" are celebrated precisely because of their rarity and the high stakes involved.
For bettors who dive into team strategies and look for tendencies toward trick plays, this market can offer opportunities to exploit pricing inefficiencies.
Community Insights on BettorEdge
BettorEdge enhances the betting experience for these unique props by fostering a collaborative and interactive environment. Their social feed is packed with real-time insights from bettors who specialize in niche markets. Users share valuable information about coaching habits, practice trends, and historical data, helping others make more informed decisions. Leaderboards also highlight top-performing bettors, offering a chance to learn from those with a proven track record in these markets.
What sets BettorEdge apart is its peer-to-peer betting model. Instead of accepting fixed odds with hidden fees, you can negotiate directly with other users, often securing better prices for these unpredictable, high-variance bets. This transparent and interactive approach makes betting on exotic props both engaging and potentially more rewarding.
Why BettorEdge Works Well for Exotic Bets
BettorEdge's peer-to-peer model eliminates the usual sportsbook markup, giving you a better shot at profitability. Traditional sportsbooks typically charge a 5–10% vigorish on prop bets, but BettorEdge connects you directly with other bettors. This setup reduces effective fees to nearly 0% for matched bets, which can make a big difference, especially for exotic Super Bowl props. Even small pricing differences on these bets can have a noticeable impact on your long-term returns.
But it’s not just about saving money - BettorEdge also makes betting more engaging with its social features. The live feed lets you see what others are betting on in real time, whether it’s the color of the Gatorade or the length of the national anthem. You can even join Super Bowl-specific groups with private chat rooms and leaderboards, where members exchange insights and data. Over 50% of users actively use these social tools, creating a collaborative environment that traditional sportsbooks just don’t offer.
Another standout feature is the ability to set custom odds. Instead of being stuck with the odds a sportsbook dictates - like for a coin flip or a non-QB touchdown - you can set your own. This flexibility is especially valuable for exotic props, where public sentiment often skews the odds. BettorEdge’s transparent order book shows you exactly what others are willing to pay, helping you secure the best value for these unpredictable bets.
On top of that, the platform includes an analytics dashboard to track your performance. It breaks down your ROI and win rates for exotic props, helping you refine your strategy. Leaderboards highlight top-performing bettors, giving you the chance to learn from those who consistently profit in these markets.
Finally, live betting windows let you adjust your bets as the game progresses. This is a game-changer for time-sensitive props, like predicting the first kickoff or the halftime show’s opening song. Since its launch, the platform has processed over $50 million in bets, with exotic prop betting volume surging 300% during the 2025 Super Bowl season.
Conclusion
With its lineup of creative prop bets, BettorEdge’s user-driven platform brings a fresh twist to the Super Bowl experience. Exotic bets like predicting the first song or guessing the Gatorade color inject fun and unpredictability into the game, making it enjoyable for fans who don’t need deep football knowledge to join in.
What sets BettorEdge apart is its peer-to-peer approach. By cutting out the sportsbook markup, the platform connects you directly with other bettors, allowing you to set your own odds without worrying about a house edge. This transparent pricing model has already proven to deliver better outcomes for users.
Beyond the bets themselves, BettorEdge turns wagering into a social experience. From anthem length discussions to debates over non-QB touchdowns, the platform fosters a sense of community, making the Super Bowl feel even more interactive.
Check out the BettorEdge marketplace to see what odds the community is offering on these six exotic bets. Join a Super Bowl group, connect with others, and take advantage of the platform’s unique peer-to-peer setup to make your Super Bowl LX bets as exciting as the game itself.
FAQs
How does BettorEdge's peer-to-peer model make betting better?
BettorEdge's peer-to-peer (P2P) model changes the game by letting users bet directly with one another rather than through a traditional bookmaker. This approach eliminates the "house edge", meaning lower fees - typically under 2% - and better odds for bettors.
The platform also gives you the freedom to set your own odds and terms, offering more control and flexibility over your wagers. On top of that, BettorEdge includes social features like bet-sharing, leaderboards, and real-time interactions, creating a lively and transparent community atmosphere. It’s a smarter and more interactive way to enjoy betting on your favorite sports.
What should I know about historical trends when betting on the Super Bowl halftime song?
When placing bets on the Super Bowl halftime show’s opening song, there’s one thing to keep in mind: unpredictability. Performers often blend their most iconic hits with unexpected choices, keeping fans and bettors guessing. The first song can depend heavily on the artist’s unique style and what they believe will captivate the audience. Since 1993, halftime shows have featured a mix of timeless crowd favorites and surprising selections, with some performers even using the moment to debut new tracks. While looking at past trends might provide some insight, the unpredictable nature of these performances is what makes this wager both thrilling and tricky.
Why is betting on the Gatorade color such a fan favorite during the Super Bowl?
Betting on the Gatorade color has become a beloved Super Bowl tradition, adding a fun twist to the big game. For decades, fans have eagerly anticipated the moment when the winning coach gets drenched, wondering which color will make its splashy appearance.
Part of the charm is how easy it is to join in - no need to be a sports expert. Anyone can get involved, making it a lighthearted way to connect with the game. The wide range of possible colors, from the ever-popular orange and blue to the occasional surprise like purple, keeps the anticipation alive and the bets interesting year after year.
